A closer look at titles with limited HDR range, weak contrast metadata or no visible upgrade over SDR. Based on technical flags, not opinions.
Some call it “Fake HDR”. We let the data speak.
🔸 What does “HDR Grading Under Review” mean?
It means the title shows signs of limited HDR quality — such as low MaxCLL/FALL values, no visible dynamic range or results that resemble SDR.
🔸 Is this the same as “Fake HDR”?
“Fake HDR” is a common term in AV circles to describe weak HDR implementations. We use “under review” to reflect technical red flags without making assumptions about intent.
🔸 What kind of data is used to flag these?
We analyze HDR metadata (Peak/Average Brightness), Dolby Vision presence, comparing against 4K Blu-Ray disc or iTunes versions. If a version appears inferior or suspicious, it’s flagged.
🔸 Can a Dolby Vision title still be weak?
Yes. Dolby Vision doesn’t guarantee quality. Some DV streams may still have low brightness values or weak tone mapping.
🔸 Are these judgements final?
No. A flagged title may still have artistic intent or future revisions. This page helps surface titles worth a second look — not to shame them.
🔸 Will this page be updated?
Yes. Titles may be added or removed as new streams, metadata or 4K Blu-ray disc comparisons become available.